Data released this week by Thomson Scientific, the global scientific community’s chief reference point for measuring research performance, show that on a per capita basis, Australia and Canada are neck and neck in leading the world in research publication output.
While the US blitzes everyone with number of papers published (3.7 times more than the second highest volume nation, Japan), when adjusted for population, the US slips to fourth, being 21% less productive than Australia and Canada on a per capita basis.
Table 1: QUANTITY: Country Total Research Papers (all fields), 1996-2006
|
Total papers 1996-2006 |
Population 2005 (m) |
Papers per capita & (ranking) |
USA |
2,907,592 |
299,846 |
0.00970 (4) |
Japan |
790,510 |
127,897 |
0.00618 (8) |
Germany |
742,917 |
82,652 |
0.00899 (5) |
UK |
660,808 |
60,245 |
0.01097 (3) |
France |
535,629 |
60,991 |
0.00878 (6) |
China |
422,993 |
1,312,979 |
0.00032 (12) |
Canada |
394,727 |
32,271 |
0.01223 (1) |
Italy |
369,138 |
58,646 |
0.00629 (7) |
Spain |
263,469 |
43,397 |
0.00607 (9) |
Australia |
248,189 |
20,310 |
0.01222 (2) |
India |
211,063 |
1,134,403 |
0.00019 (13) |
South Korea |
180,329 |
47,870 |
0.00377 (11) |
Taiwan |
124,940 |
22,859 |
0.00545 (10) |
The key measure of research quality is the number of times other researchers cite a paper. Well over half of all papers published are never cited by anyone. Table 2 shows that the US blitzes the field in having more than 5.4 times as many papers in the “top 1% most cited” list, and keeps its lead when adjustment is made for population size. Australia ranks seventh in the number of papers in the top 1%, but moves to fourth when adjusted for population size.
Table 2: QUALITY: Papers per country in top 1% most cited
Top 1% most cited |
Population 2005 (m) |
Papers per capita & (ranking) |
|
USA |
54,516 |
299,846 |
0.1818 (1) |
UK |
10,090 |
60,245 |
0.1675 (2) |
Germany |
9,427 |
82,652 |
0.1141 (5) |
France |
5,967 |
60,991 |
0.0978 (6) |
Japan |
5,662 |
127,897 |
0.0443 (9) |
Canada |
5,301 |
32,271 |
0.1643 (3) |
Italy |
3,825 |
58,646 |
0.0652 (6) |
Australia |
2,804 |
20,310 |
0.1381 (4) |
China |
2,189 |
1,312,979 |
0.0016 (11) |
Spain |
2,155 |
43,397 |
0.0497 (7) |
South Korea |
929 |
47,870 |
0.0194 (10) |
India |
694 |
1,134,403 |
0.0006 (12) |
Taiwan |
550 |
22,859 |
0.0241 (9) |
Calculated from Thomson scientific figures and 2005 population data here.
Crikey is committed to hosting lively discussions. Help us keep the conversation useful, interesting and welcoming. We aim to publish comments quickly in the interest of promoting robust conversation, but we’re a small team and we deploy filters to protect against legal risk. Occasionally your comment may be held up while we review, but we’re working as fast as we can to keep the conversation rolling.
The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Please subscribe to leave a comment.
The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Please login to leave a comment.