As we know, Facebook last week took aim at the big players in the Australian media and ended up wounding dozens of little ones. My news website, The Terrier, based in Warrnambool in regional Victoria, was hit right in the bum by the shrapnel.
Bang! The Terrier was wiped off Facebook overnight and the 5300-plus followers I have so diligently built up these past three years evaporated.
I quickly started a “Terrier florist” page on Facebook, just to maintain some oxygen. I’m not pushing up the daisies just yet — and besides Facebook has now seen the error of its ways. We’re back.
I am, however, mulling over what is a sustainable and realistic way to get through a bigger issue: what Mark Zuckerberg has exposed is the soft underbelly of hyper-local media voices like The Terrier.
We are the little tackers trying to keep independent, public interest journalism alive in regional corners of Australia like Warrnambool and Cygnet and Manning River and Naracoorte.
It’s an exhausting battle with multiple fronts that go beyond our reliance on social media as a platform from which to be heard and shared.
It also includes our vulnerability in defamation claims, another of which landed literally on my doorstep just days before Facebook pulled the pin.
It’s my fourth claim in 18 months. All relate to my ongoing investigation into an aged care facility.
I must respond to these claims, irrespective of whether they can be substantiated. Fortunately I have insurance via the Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance, but that does not mean my legal representation is free: each action attracts a $2000 excess.
This leaves new hyper-locals like The Terrier open to “bullying by bank balance” whereby a cashed-up organisation or individual can continue to launch civil actions for the cost of a legal letter.
For those hoping to shut down an investigative journalist, it is a very cheap and effective silencer.
Google, Facebook, and the federal government have been fighting over money that many hyper-locals will never see, because under the new media code, to even negotiate with Facebook and the like, a media organisation must make at least $150,000 a year.
In the past two years, I have made nowhere near that, even as The Terrier has proven that regional readers are desperate for investigative journalism that is not afraid to challenge those in charge.
But desperation is not enough.
I had hoped the government might use the code to launch a public interest journalism fund that all media outlets could apply for, no matter how big or small, provided that outlet could prove it had journalistic runs on the board.
The Terrier has some significant runs, including the launch of an inquiry by the Victorian Ombudsman into credit card abuse at my local council and the complete replacement of that council in last year’s October elections.
Again, it is not enough. There is still no fund. The cavalry is yet to crest the horizon.
I keep hanging in there, because this fight is much bigger than Facebook and much broader than Google and strikes at the heart of whether hyper-local, public interest, and investigative journalism really does have a future.
I feel we are now standing at that crossroad of yes or no.
As it sits, the legacy media companies stand to get stronger, yet with no guarantees their regional newsrooms will get bigger. Meanwhile, the smaller voices stand to be crushed.
Last week was a whack that I didn’t see coming, and it hurt. But terriers are tough.
We open “florist shops” on Facebook, we take a little time to smell the roses, and we keep working with those who want us to survive.
Crikey is committed to hosting lively discussions. Help us keep the conversation useful, interesting and welcoming. We aim to publish comments quickly in the interest of promoting robust conversation, but we’re a small team and we deploy filters to protect against legal risk. Occasionally your comment may be held up while we review, but we’re working as fast as we can to keep the conversation rolling.
The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Please subscribe to leave a comment.
The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Please login to leave a comment.